Crystal is sold at several times the price of ordinary glass on the claim that it is a materially better vessel. Some of that is true, and the traditional formulation carries a caveat worth understanding.
What crystal is
Ordinary glassware is soda-lime glass, made from silica, soda ash and lime.
Traditional lead crystal adds lead oxide, historically at twenty four per cent or more. The lead increases the refractive index, making the glass sparkle, and lowers the working temperature, which allows it to be blown thinner and cut more deeply.
Modern lead-free crystal replaces the lead with other metal oxides, commonly barium, zinc or titanium, achieving similar optical properties without the lead.
The genuine advantages
Thinness is the one that matters most for drinking. Crystal can be blown considerably thinner than soda-lime glass, and a fine rim delivers liquid more pleasantly than a thick rolled one.
This is the difference most people actually notice, and it is real rather than imagined.
Clarity and brilliance are genuine optical properties, which matters for appearance rather than for taste.
The traditional claim that a microscopically rougher surface aids aeration in wine is sometimes made and is not well established.
The lead question
Worth addressing directly rather than avoiding.
Lead can leach from lead crystal into acidic liquids, and the rate increases substantially with contact time. Research has consistently found that brief contact, meaning the time a drink spends in a glass, results in negligible transfer.
Prolonged storage is a different matter. Spirits kept in a lead crystal decanter for months or years can accumulate measurable quantities of lead, and this has been documented in published studies.
Guidance from food safety bodies has generally been that lead crystal is acceptable for serving and not for long-term storage. Some authorities advise against using lead crystal for anything intended for children or for people who are pregnant.
Anyone with specific concerns should look at current guidance from a food standards authority rather than rely on a general article, and anyone worried about lead exposure should raise it with a doctor.
The practical position
Using lead crystal glasses for drinking is not something most guidance treats as a concern.
Using a lead crystal decanter to store spirits for extended periods is where the caution applies, and the straightforward answer is to decant only what will be drunk within a few days, or to use a lead-free decanter.
Inherited crystal is common and the same applies: enjoy the glasses, and do not keep whisky in the decanter for a decade.
Lead-free crystal
Now the standard for new production from most manufacturers, and it removes the question entirely.
It achieves comparable thinness, clarity and brilliance, and it is generally more durable than lead crystal, which is soft and scratches.
Many are dishwasher safe, which lead crystal is not.
Is it worth the money
For anything where the rim matters, meaning wine and spirits drunk attentively, a fine rim is a genuine improvement and crystal delivers it.
For beer, cocktails with ice, and anything robust, ordinary glass is entirely adequate and considerably less likely to break.
Good soda-lime glassware with a thin rim exists and costs a fraction of crystal, which is the sensible middle option for most households.
Looking after it
Hand wash lead crystal, which is soft and etches easily in a dishwasher.
Store upright, avoid rapid temperature changes, and hold by the bowl rather than twisting the stem.
Identifying it
Crystal rings when tapped, with a sustained note, where soda-lime glass produces a duller sound.
It is also noticeably heavier for its thickness and refracts light more visibly.
Modern lead-free crystal shares these properties, so the ring test tells you it is crystal rather than telling you whether it contains lead. Anything bought new from a mainstream manufacturer in recent years is almost certainly lead-free.
Inherited pieces
Older crystal is likely to contain lead, and using it for serving is not something guidance treats as a concern.
The caution is about storage, so a decanter is the piece to think about rather than the glasses.